A legal and ethical crisis has emerged after a Monash IVF clinic in Brisbane mistakenly implanted the wrong embryo into a patient, leading her to unknowingly give birth to another woman’s child. Experts are calling the situation a “nightmare” with no precedent in Australian law.
Monash IVF, which operates across Australia, has expressed regret over the error, attributing it to “human error” and assuring the public that it believes this to be an isolated incident.
The mix-up raises complex family law questions, according to Frances Bertram, the leader of Shine Lawyers’ Queensland medical negligence practice. “This situation leads to various custody concerns, as it raises the question of who should raise the child—the biological parents or the parents who carried and gave birth to the child?” Bertram explained, adding that the implications could be far-reaching.
Bertram warned that all parties involved could be entitled to significant compensation, should they pursue legal action. The emotional toll of the case on both the biological and birth families could be profound and long-lasting. “For the families, the psychological impact could be severe, especially during milestones like Mother’s Day or Christmas,” she said.
Sarah Jefford, a family creation lawyer, stated that this case could set a new legal precedent in Australia, where the presumption typically holds that the birth parents are the legal parents. Whether the genetic parents will seek to claim their child remains uncertain.
Dr. Hugh Breakey, a senior research fellow in moral philosophy at Griffith University, described the case as an “incredible ethical tangle.” He emphasized that the situation involves two legitimate claims that cannot both be fully realized. “It’s not about what we are owed, but what the child is owed,” Breakey said.
The case has raised concerns among donor-conceived individuals, many of whom have been advocating for stronger disclosure laws and the creation of a national register. Monash IVF recently settled a $56 million class action in 2024 after over 700 patients claimed that faulty genetic screening had led to the destruction of embryos. The company reached the settlement through mediation, though it did not admit liability.
Katherine Dawson, a donor-conceived person, expressed her concerns that the mistake may have gone unnoticed without Queensland’s laws requiring disclosure. “If these checks and balances are being missed, there needs to be more record-keeping and more transparency,” Dawson said.
Professor Gab Kovacs, a leading IVF specialist, noted that while such mistakes are rare, errors do occur, particularly in the handling of sperm and eggs. He acknowledged that cases involving the wrong embryo being implanted have happened overseas and emphasized the rigorous protocols already in place to prevent such errors.
Monash IVF CEO Michael Knaap apologized for the incident, assuring that additional audits had been conducted and reiterating that this was a one-off occurrence. “We are devastated by the situation and extend our sincerest apologies to everyone involved,” Knaap said.
Related topics:
