Contraception, a cornerstone of reproductive health, is experiencing a shift. A significant number of people are not using it, and many are turning away from traditional methods. Columnist Martha Gill, writing in The Guardian, highlights a concerning trend where contraception has stagnated for decades, now becoming a subject of cultural battles and wellness debates. She calls for innovative ideas and better contraceptive options, particularly for men.
Declining Use of the Contraceptive Pill
Recent data shows a notable decline in the use of the contraceptive pill in England, with prescriptions dropping from 432,600 in 2014 to 188,500 in 2021. Alarmingly, research from abortion clinics reveals that many women are turning to natural methods after discontinuing the pill. A comparison of contraceptive methods used by women seeking abortions in 2018 and 2023 showed an increase in smartphone-based menstrual tracking from 0.4% to 2.5%, while the use of hormonal methods fell. Furthermore, the proportion of women not using any contraception at the time of pregnancy jumped from 50% to 70%.
The Role of Cultural and Social Movements
Several factors are contributing to this decline. A conservative backlash, particularly in the U.S., has fueled negative perceptions of birth control. Figures like Alex Clark and Candace Owens have spread misinformation about the pill, suggesting false links to infertility and health issues. In parallel, the wellness movement’s focus on “natural” remedies rather than medically-proven solutions has gained traction. Social media platforms like TikTok and Instagram amplify these voices, with videos exaggerating the pill’s side effects, gaining millions of views and spreading misinformation.
The result? A growing hesitancy toward hormonal birth control, especially among younger generations, driven by unsubstantiated fears and exaggerated anecdotes.
The Need for Better Contraceptives
While public health officials are working to counteract the spread of misinformation—particularly the dangerous myth that birth control causes infertility—there is an underlying issue that remains largely unaddressed: the need for better contraceptives. Current methods, including condoms, IUDs, and hormonal pills, have significant limitations. Condoms often fail, IUDs can be painful and invasive, and hormonal methods are associated with side effects such as headaches, weight gain, acne, and mood changes.
Approximately one-third of women discontinue the contraceptive pill within the first year, often due to concerns about health and side effects. Despite these drawbacks, women continue to use these methods, with little alternative available.
Why Is Contraception Stagnant?
The question that needs to be asked is not just whether we should abandon current methods, but why contraceptives haven’t improved over the years. Many women are still using the same birth control methods their mothers or even grandmothers used. The problem lies in the limited innovation in the field. While new contraceptive products often spark excitement, there has been little research into improving existing methods. Between 2017 and 2020, there were only 20-25 clinical trials funded by the industry for contraceptives, compared to 600 for cardiovascular drugs in 2019 alone. Despite pharmaceutical companies reinvesting 20% of their revenue into R&D for most drugs, the figure for contraception stands at only 2%.
One of the reasons for this lack of progress is the higher safety and litigation risks associated with drugs given to a healthy population, which discourages investment.
Market Growth Despite Dissatisfaction
Despite widespread dissatisfaction with current contraceptive options, the market for contraceptives continues to grow, with many women resigning themselves to the trade-offs. As a result, there has been no significant market signal demanding change. The culture of contraception mirrors broader societal attitudes. While conservative forces attack birth control, it was they who hindered its research in the first place, often expecting women to tolerate the side effects.
Hope on the Horizon for Men’s Contraceptives
While female contraceptives have stagnated, there is hope emerging for men. Innovative contraceptive methods for men, such as a gel that can be applied to the arms and shoulders to block fertility without affecting mood or libido, are being developed. Historically, when male contraceptive trials involved side effects like mood swings and depression, similar to those experienced by women, the trials were halted. However, the potential for better options for men could ease the burden on women, providing them with alternatives to traditional methods.
Moreover, innovations for male contraception could lead to improvements in female contraceptives as well, as the bar for safety and effectiveness is raised across the board. However, there is a risk that focusing too much on male contraception could divert resources and attention from much-needed advancements for women, especially given that nearly half of all pregnancies worldwide are unintended.
The Urgency of Change
The need for better contraceptives has never been more urgent. As the availability of effective birth control remains essential, the continued dissatisfaction with current methods demands immediate action. As the global landscape of contraception evolves, it is clear that new, innovative solutions are needed for both men and women to ensure equitable access to effective reproductive health care.
Related topics:
Can Endometriosis Cause Bloating?
