In a contentious vote, Senate Republicans have once again thwarted proposed legislation to establish a nationwide right to in vitro fertilization (IVF). This marks the second attempt this year by Democrats to secure federal protections for IVF, which Republicans dismiss as a politically motivated maneuver aimed at influencing the election.
The Senate vote concluded with a 51-44 tally, falling short of the 60 votes required to advance the bill. Only two Republicans supported the measure, with Democrats accusing their counterparts of hypocrisy. Illinois Senator Tammy Duckworth, the bill’s lead sponsor and a military veteran who benefited from IVF to have her children, criticized Republicans for their unwillingness to codify their professed support for the treatment into law.
The legislative push gained momentum following a ruling by the Alabama Supreme Court that classified frozen embryos as children under state law. This decision led to a temporary halt in IVF treatments at several clinics until the Alabama legislature enacted protective measures. Democrats capitalized on the opportunity, introducing the bill in June as a safeguard against potential future restrictions following the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2022 decision overturning abortion rights.
The proposed bill aims to guarantee nationwide access to IVF and other assisted reproductive technologies, mandate broader insurance coverage, and extend benefits to military service members and veterans. Vice President Kamala Harris condemned the Republican block, stating that the GOP has once again failed to protect access to vital fertility treatments.
Republican vice-presidential candidate and Ohio Senator JD Vance, who was absent from the vote due to campaigning, dismissed the bill as a political stunt designed to embarrass Republicans. Vance characterized the measure as a “showboat” with little chance of passing.
Republicans argue that the bill represents an overreach of federal authority and an unserious proposal. Only Senators Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska broke ranks with their party to support the bill. In response, many Republicans have reiterated their support for IVF, with former President Donald Trump recently proposing, without specifics, that health insurance or the federal government should cover the treatment.
Senator John Thune, the No. 2 Senate Republican, accused Democrats of fabricating a political issue, asserting that Republicans unequivocally support IVF. However, some state laws adopted by Republican-led legislatures have granted personhood to embryos, complicating the party’s stance on IVF. The Republican Party’s recent policy platform supports fetal personhood through the 14th Amendment while also endorsing IVF without clarifying implementation details.
In attempts to address the issue, Republicans have proposed alternative measures, such as legislation to prevent state bans on IVF, but these have been blocked by Democrats. Senator Rick Scott of Florida, whose daughter is undergoing IVF, has suggested expanding health savings accounts as a potential solution. Senators Katie Britt and Ted Cruz have pushed for bills threatening to withhold Medicaid funding from states with IVF bans. Cruz, campaigning for re-election, criticized Democrats for using IVF as a tool to advance their broader political agenda.
Related topics:
